Estimated Reading Time: 3-4 Minutes
Facing a denied insurance claim can be frustrating and financially overwhelming. When your insurance company refuses to cover damage to your home, you might wonder if switching to a different insurer is the solution. At Holbrook Leavitt & Associates PLLC, we help Oklahoma homeowners navigate these complex situations every day. While changing insurance providers is possible after a denial, it's important to understand the implications, timing, and alternative options available to you.
Understanding Why Claims Get Denied
Before considering a switch, it's crucial to understand why your claim was denied. Insurance companies may deny claims for various reasons.
These include:
Policy Exclusions - The damage may fall outside your coverage
Lack of Maintenance - Pre-existing conditions or neglect
Late Reporting - Missing claim filing deadlines
Insufficient Documentation - Inadequate proof of damage or value
Coverage Lapses - Gaps in policy payments
Understanding the denial reason helps determine whether switching insurers will actually solve your problem or if you need to take a different approach.
Can You Switch Insurance After a Denial?
Yes, you can technically switch home insurance providers after a claim denial, but this decision comes with important considerations. When you apply for new home insurance, providers will ask about your claims history. A recent denial typically must be disclosed, and this information can affect your ability to secure new coverage.
Insurance companies may:
Decline Coverage Entirely - Some insurers won't accept applicants with recent denied claims
Charge Higher Premiums - You may face increased rates due to perceived risk
Impose Exclusions - New policies might exclude coverage for the previously denied damage type
Require Waiting Periods - Certain coverages may not take effect immediately
Additionally, switching insurance companies will not provide coverage for damage that already exists. New policies cover future incidents, not past damage, even if your previous insurer denied the claim. If you have existing storm damage, fire damage, or other issues, a new policy won't help you recover those losses.
Better Alternatives to Switching Insurance
1. Appeal the Denial
Most insurance policies include an appeals process. You can:
Request a detailed explanation of the denial in writing
Gather additional documentation to support your claim
Hire a public adjuster for an independent assessment
Submit a formal appeal within the specified timeframe
2. Consult with an Insurance Claims Attorney
An experienced attorney can review your policy, assess the denial's validity, and identify potential bad faith practices. At Holbrook Leavitt & Associates PLLC, we specialize in helping Oklahoma homeowners challenge wrongful denials and fight for the compensation they deserve.
Many denials are based on misinterpretations of policy language, incomplete investigations, or deliberate undervaluation. Legal representation can level the playing field against large insurance companies.
3. File a Complaint with the Oklahoma Insurance Department
If you believe your claim was wrongfully denied, you can file a complaint with the Oklahoma Insurance Department. They can investigate whether your insurer violated state regulations or engaged in unfair claims practices.
4. Document Everything
Whether you choose to appeal, seek legal help, or file a complaint:
Keep copies of all correspondence with your insurer
Take detailed photos and videos of the damage
Obtain independent repair estimates
Save receipts for temporary repairs or emergency expenses
Note dates and details of all phone conversations
When Switching Makes Sense
While switching insurers won't help with an existing denied claim, there are situations where finding new coverage is appropriate.
These may include:
After Resolving Your Current Claim - Once your denied claim is settled or resolved, shopping for better coverage makes sense
Poor Customer Service - Consistent communication issues or disrespectful treatment
Better Rates Elsewhere - If you're not pursuing the denied claim further, competitive shopping may save money
Policy Renewal Time - Natural transition point to explore other options
However, even in these cases, be prepared to explain the previous denial to prospective insurers.
Protect Your Rights and Your Home
A denied insurance claim doesn't have to be the final word. Before making any decisions about switching insurers, explore your options for challenging the denial. Insurance companies count on policyholders accepting denials without question, but you have rights under Oklahoma law.
At Holbrook Leavitt & Associates PLLC, we work on a contingency fee basis, meaning you pay nothing unless we win your case. We understand that damage to your home creates significant financial stress. Led by founding attorney Ashley Leavitt, we're committed to holding insurance companies accountable when they fail to honor their obligations.
Don't let a denied claim force you into an expensive or ineffective insurance switch. Contact us online or call (918) 992-2330 today to schedule a free consultation. We'll review your denial, explain your options, and work to secure the compensation you deserve.
Holbrook Leavitt & Associates PLLC represents Oklahoma homeowners in property insurance disputes and bad faith insurance claims. We serve clients throughout Tulsa and the surrounding areas.